And while the attractive pair were rumored to be dating for about three years, the former Yankees star was known almost as much for his romantic life as he was for his five-time World Series championships.
No more random dating, but maybe the pride of Kalamazoo didn't expect a ring to come between him and his beloved Michigan team.
And, after Davis posted this photo of someone who has to be Jeets dressed as the devil, she seemed to understand:
Choosing between a wolverine and fox? No question who won.When it's Halloween and you're ready to go out.. but Michigan is on haha pic.twitter.com/0ysBV1R9Xe— Hannah Davis (@hanni_davis) November 1, 2015